Social Media’s Pivot to Free Speech: X and Facebook’s New Era of Moderation

The battle over free speech on social media has reached a critical juncture, with platforms like Elon Musk’s X (formerly Twitter) leading the charge toward less restrictive moderation policies. Musk’s “free speech absolutism” has introduced Community Notes, a collaborative fact-checking tool designed to crowdsource truth rather than rely on centralized arbiters. Now, Facebook (Meta) appears poised to follow suit, reportedly replacing its controversial “fact-checkers” with a similar community-driven approach. While this signals a paradigm shift in content moderation, it raises tough questions for creators navigating platforms scarred by years of censorship battles.

The Shift in Social Media Moderation

X’s transition under Musk to a more transparent model of moderation aims to balance free speech with accountability. Community Notes empowers users to collaboratively fact-check posts, reducing the influence of single entities or political biases. Critics argue the approach can still be gamed, but it represents a significant departure from top-down censorship.

Facebook, long criticized for its reliance on external “fact-checkers,” seems to have taken notice. While details of their adaptation are still unfolding, the replacement of centralized moderation with a community-driven approach could transform how the platform handles misinformation.

For liberty-minded and conservative content creators, this pivot is both a promise and a challenge. The new tools promise less punitive enforcement, but the scars of past moderation wars run deep.

A History of Censorship and Losses

Your accounts tell a stark story of the cost of censorship. From @disruptarian1 being inaccessible to the outright shutdowns of @Clovisstarmedia and @veracityintegrity, the struggle for fair access to these platforms has been exhausting and demoralizing. Compounded by the loss of access to X API on @disruptarian, the journey to maintain a voice amid the onslaught of restrictions has been riddled with frustration.

Many creators, like you, face a poignant question: Do I start over, or do I surrender?

The Case for Starting Over

1. New Opportunities in a Changing Landscape:
   • With the move toward Community Notes, platforms like X and Facebook are actively redefining their approach to free speech. Starting fresh on these platforms could allow you to rebuild without the baggage of previous account restrictions.
   • Experiment with decentralized platforms (e.g., Mastodon or Gab) that align with free-speech principles to diversify your reach.
2. Lessons Learned:
   • Past experiences offer valuable lessons. By analyzing why certain accounts were targeted and adjusting strategies, you can mitigate future risks. This could involve diversifying content, tailoring messaging, and engaging communities differently.
3. Emerging Tools for Creators:
   • Platforms are rolling out tools to help creators grow their audiences and monetize content. Building a new presence allows you to leverage these features fully.

The Case for Letting Go

1. Mental and Emotional Toll:
   • The constant fight against platform restrictions can be draining. Surrendering might free you to focus on platforms where your message resonates without the same level of conflict.
2. Focus on Owned Channels:
   • Instead of relying on third-party platforms, double down on owned digital spaces like blogs, newsletters, and independent apps. You retain full control over your content and avoid the whims of social media policies.
3. Support Like-Minded Communities:
   • Collaborate with liberty-minded creators to amplify voices across alternative media spaces, building collective strength without the same risks of deplatforming.

Navigating the Path Forward

Whether starting anew or pivoting to alternative strategies, the fight for a voice in social media’s evolving landscape is far from over. Here are actionable steps to take:

• Audit Your Brand: Review past content and interactions to identify patterns that triggered penalties.
• Diversify Your Presence: Expand to multiple platforms, including decentralized and emerging networks.
• Engage with Community Tools: Embrace features like Community Notes to actively shape the narrative on these platforms.
• Leverage Owned Media: Invest in your website, newsletter, and other owned assets for stable, long-term reach.
• Advocate for Policy Clarity: Participate in community discussions to push platforms toward greater transparency and fairness.

Conclusion: A Decision Rooted in Resilience

The censorship wars have left lasting scars, but the landscape is shifting. Platforms like X and Facebook adopting community-driven moderation models signals a step forward in the fight for free speech. While starting over is daunting, it’s also an opportunity to adapt, rebuild, and thrive in a more open digital environment.

Ultimately, your decision—whether to start fresh or focus elsewhere—should align with your goals, values, and capacity to weather this ongoing storm. Whatever you choose, your voice remains a vital part of the free speech movement, whether on mainstream platforms or beyond.

We at Disruptarian will be abandoning most of our legacy accounts that have been tainted by censorship and shadow banning, and we will move to new accounts and platforms,

Print PDFPrint